Findings
2.1 Coming out is difficult for almost all LGBT people. For many Muslim
LBT women, coming out to themselves and coming out to their family
and friends can be further complicated due to issues relating to culture
or religion. (See also under Identity &Mental Health) For many
Muslim LBT women the consequences of coming out to family and friends
are devastating.
2.2 Often coming out, or ‘being outed ’
by someone else, results in negative reactions from family and friends.
These reactions can include (complete) rejection, sometimes leading
to isolation; intensified pressure to get married, sometimes leading
to forced marriage; physical or emotional domestic violence; and/or
the loss of custody or contact with children. Coming out can also result
in the sudden loss of all support systems and therefore affects matters
such as housing, education and employment. (See also under the relevant
headings.)
2.3 The reaction of (ex-) husbands (or other family
members) to a Muslim LBT woman coming out is diverse. For example, some
husbands have been understanding to some extent, but still insisted
their wife ‘keep up appearances ’ whilst others became violent.
Many women thought that male peer pressure in Muslim communities encouraged
domestic violence. (See also under Domestic Violence.)
2.4 Class is a distinctly important factor in determining
the effects of coming out. According to the experience of the Muslim
LBT women informing the Safra Project, families from a middle or upper
class background are more likely to have a more liberal attitude towards
personal freedom and are therefore more likely to be tolerant. Women
from these backgrounds are also more likely to have an education, be
employed, they are therefore less dependent on their families.
2.5 Even coming out to peers can result in isolation.
Some Muslim LBT women indicated that they have not been taken seriously
or simply not believed when they have come out to friends. One young
woman was forced to leave her college when, after confiding in a friend,
rumours spread and people began talking about her negatively. Existing
support groups for Asian women in schools and colleges are often hostile
towards LGBT issues.
2.6 Some social workers don ’t feel able to
talk to Muslim parents about the sexual orientation issues of their
children because they are afraid that they would be acting in a culturally
insensitive or racist manner. This leaves young LGBT Muslims who have
run away from home, or who have problems at home (including domestic
violence), to deal with the ‘coming out ’ process on their
own.2.2
2.7 Married or divorced Muslim LBT mothers fear loosing
custody, or even abduction, of their children if they come out or are
found out. Some mothers found it extremely difficult to come out to
their children because they feared being rejection by them. (See also
under Marriage and Children.)
2.8 In mainstream LGBT circles there can be lot of
pressure to come out. However, explicitly coming out to family and friends
is not, at all times or in all situations, viable or safe for Muslim
LBT women. Some may have found a certain balance in their life where
they maintain contact with their family whilst leading their own life
on a mutual ‘don ’t ask don ’t tell ’ basis.
The gains of coming out in such a situation do not always outweigh the
losses or (physical) risks.
2.10 There is a need for inclusive workshops and support
groups throughout the UK where Muslim LBT women would be able to share
experiences and find the support that they need to come out to themselves
and their friends and families. Particular attention should be paid to
issues such as (forced) marriage, dealing with (ex-) husbands, divorce
and children.
2.11 Support for (young) LGBT people coming out should not be compromised
in the name of cultural sensitivity.
2.12 Existing mainstream LGBT support groups need to
be more aware of issues such as the possible consequences of coming out
for Muslim LBT women.